Measure the Impact of Consumer Activism

I practice values-based spending and was eager to read early reports about the recent nationwide no-spend day on February 28th, driven by consumer activism.
​
The current financial analysis about the impacts to companies at the center of the one-day boycott is too narrow — focused on a one-day dip in foot traffic and sales. At the same time, I appreciate the reporting because the public doesn’t have access to high-level KPIs and won’t for months.

I read one quote equating the overall impact of February 28th to one rainy day and analyzed it as a dismissal of every person who participated. But, the follow-up call for a long-term business fast? That will have undeniable impacts.

Q1 retail sales reports from publicly traded companies won’t be available until Thursday, May 8, 2025, followed by deeper news analysis. Until then, I’ll share how I apply retail knowledge to assess economic activism and the news cycle.

🧭 Four Pillars of Merchant Method™: Behavior reflects insight
📚 Merchant Skills: Connect short-term actions with the big picture
✏️ Your Assignment: Measure your business agility
📌 Bulletin Board: Leadership, agility, and professional development

🧭 FOUR PILLARS OF MERCHANT METHOD
Knowledge-to-action continuum

Retailers use industry benchmarks to set goals, track trends, and stay informed. Yet knowledge alone isn’t enough. How you put that knowledge to action is what matters.

Note: The Venn diagram of the Four Pillars of Merchant Method for inventory-based business owners has revised labels and descriptions.

New to the Merchant Method or need a refresher? Get oriented.

📚 MERCHANT SKILLS
The context that shapes your view

Here are four retail truths to keep in mind when evaluating consumer activism:

• Customer traffic and revenue aren’t cause and effect. No single factor guarantees that a shopper will become a buyer.
• Customer conversion is about relationships, not just transactions. Customers spend where they feel connected and valued. When they feel strongly about a negative experience, they do more than withhold spending.
• It takes time to win back customers and restore customer relationships. Assortment decisions play out over time. We don’t see the results of buying, supporting inventory, and merchandising choices right away.
• Measurable marketing ROI takes patience because results take two times as long as the sales cycle. If your business’ selling seasons are SPR/SMR and FAL/HOL, marketing efforts from March 2025 will likely show up in March 2026.

What could that mean for studying the impact of nationwide consumer activism?

We know we won’t see lasting impact right away so let’s focus on how businesses respond over time:

• Watch the companies you’ve chosen not to support. How do they adjust their messaging, marketing, and customer engagement?
• Pay attention to how retailers convert traffic into sales. What levers are they using—assortment, collaborations, promotions, or staffing changes?
• Talk about it with your team. These conversations strengthen professional knowledge and help you sharpen your own strategic thinking.
• Build a research habit. Check in once a month, especially in the second fiscal week, when media analysis drops after earnings reports.

Consumer activism is an ongoing practice, reflected in both words and spending habits.

✍ YOUR ASSIGNMENT
Flex your small business super power

Retailers seldom have the luxury of waiting and seeing. We need to respond in real-time and the agility you have in a small business is an asset. How well does your business adjust to change?

​This week, measure your business agility.

Responsiveness: How quickly can you meet or exceed your customers' needs with ready-to-go products, services, operations?

Collaboration: Do your employees work well together? Are communication and contributions meaningful across different areas of your business?

Resilience: How well do you anticipate challenges and navigate around them? When setbacks happen, how effectively do you recover?

Agility isn’t just about speed. It’s also about making smart moves at the right time.

📌 BULLETIN BOARD
Leading through change, even your own

Every retailer must master their own business agility. We can’t predict every challenge, but we can prepare for them. Check out Agilemania’s business agility tutorial for quick, effective lessons.